If things always went the way they do in my head...the following would have happened:

I ran into my sister's friend the other day. We saw each other outside of the bagel place, but didn't actually say anything until we ran into each other again at Starbucks.

"I didn't recognize you because you got your hair cut!" she squealed.

"Funny, I didn't recognize you because your face was all scrunched up and squinty."